Saturday, 14 March 2009

In My Mailbox - 15 March

In My Mailbox comes from the delightful brains of Story Siren and Pop Culture Junkie.

The fantabulous, soon to be published, Karen Mahoney sent me some titles from my wish list:
A Great and Terrible Beauty - Libba Bray (review coming)
Dead Girl Walking - LJ Singleton


Mo Johnson (Aust.) sent me her soon to be released Something More. She also sent my class a set of signed cover prints which made their term. Thank you so much, from me and them!

Review Copies:
The Phoenix Files: Arrival - Chris Morphew
Numbers - Rachel Ward
Gone - Michael Grant
Quentaris: The Gimlet Eye - James Roy (Aust.)

Bought (I don't know why, call me crazy):
Coraline - Neil Gaiman
The Shadow Thief - Alexandra Adornetto (Aust.)
Lucy Zeelou's Goal - Liz Deep-Jones (Aust.)
Princess Ben - Catherine Gilbert Murdock (not all pictured)

Vampire Academy: Shadow Kiss / Richelle Mead

Summary - Is Rose's fate to kill the person she loves most? It's springtime at St. Vladimir's Academy, and Rose Hathaway is this close to graduation. Since Mason's death, Rose hasn't been feeling quite right. She has dark flashbacks in the middle of practice, can't concentrate in class, and has terrifying dreams about Lissa. But Rose has an even bigger secret . . . .She's in love with Dimitri. And this time, it's way more than a crush.

Then Strigoi target the academy in the deadliest attack in Moroi history, and Dimitri is taken. Rose must protect Lissa at all costs, but keeping her best friend safe could mean losing Dimitri forever.

Review - This will be short:

Positives - Rose being selfish in a good way in terms of Dimitri's destiny, Christian and Rose encounters, Rose's Mum, Dimitri, Eddie and his new found confidence. Strigoi attack. Eddie ghost. Explanation of how Lissa's powers affect Rose. Bow-chica-wow-wow. Lissa and Rose confrontation of the last few pages - hurrah.

Negatives - Adrian - can't stand him, Mana - blech, Lissa - ugh. The palace -mnah.

Determination - I will read fourth book but better stay on track.

Published: 2008
Format: Paperback, 442 pages
Publisher: Penguin Aust.
Origin: USA

Portraits of Snarktress

My students gifted me with drawings of myself. Cuteness.
(Except that I don't think my legs are supermodel-y, like on the left or tree trunks, like on the right.)

Soundtrack Saturday (6)

Soundtrack Saturday - link something you are reading with a song, a playlist, etc and tell me about it! (Instructions in top link bar)

I have been reading the Vampire Academy books this week in an attempt to give my brain a much needed break. Surprisingly, I found Frostbite and Shadowkiss to be much more fluid than the former.

The one song that was flooding my brains when reading this novel was:
Psycho Killer - Talking Heads
I can’t seem to face up to the facts.
I’m tense and nervous and I... can’t relax.
I can’t sleep, cause my bed’s on fire.
Don’t touch me I’m a real live wire.

Psycho KillerQu'est-ce que c'est?
fa fa fa fa fa fa fa fa fa fa better
Run run run run run run run away
OH OH OH

Psycho Killer
Qu'est-ce que c'est?
fa fa fa fa fa fa fa fa fa fa better
Run run run run run run run away
OH OH OH AY AY AY AY AY WOO

And that's how I feel about this series in general, that words cannot describe (and I don't mean in a positive way either.)

Here's Aussie Kate Miller Heidke doing her bonkers spin on the song:

Friday, 13 March 2009

Guest Blog: Sandy Fussell

Sandy Fussell's been a great sport taking part in this week's Author Spotlight. I would like to offer my thanks for being one of the nicest people to correspond with in the entirety of the universe. Look out for her Samurai Kids series on shelves now (in Australia) and soon (in the USA).

Being a children’s author can be quite confronting. Embarrassing even. The questions some primary students ask range from jaw-dropping to ego shattering. And on other occasions they can make you feel like Master of the (Writing) Universe. I thought I’d blog about one of my MOTWU moments. I don’t want to mention the others!!!

Back in June 2008 I was guest of honour at the Henry Lawson Festival of the Arts in Grenfell. Grenfell is a tiny rural town in the central west of NSW, population 2200, the birthplace of Henry Lawson. The weekend long Festival is very prestigious. It’s the longest running arts festival in Australia and past guests of honour have included Patrick White, Di Morrissey and Thomas Keneally!

So how did I get this gig? Well, I’m not proud. I’m willing to admit I was the Guest of Honour to Be Named Later. Last Minute actually. TV actor Simon Westaway was the original choice and when he had to cancel, the rush was on to find someone arts-related who would come to Grenfell at extremely short notice. My sister, who lives on a small farm in the area, happened to mention me. Even if she wasn’t the best sister in the world this would have immediately earned her the dedication in Shaolin Tiger!

My sister is an author,” she said. “And she visits here all the time.”

So there I was, pretending to be a famous person of literary note. Crowning the beauty queens. Cutting the ribbon. Keynote speaker at the dinner. Presenting trophies and medallions. Conducting TV interviews. Chatting with the writers from Underbelly who were accepting a scriptwriting award.

Grenfell opened its heart to welcome me. I think the townspeople were sort of proud that I had a local connection. I might not have been the ilk of the previous guests yet I was an honorary ‘one of their own.”

But my really big moment was absolutely huge. It’s one of the highlights of my writing career. I was sitting on the official dais (trying to look official and literary!) watching the street parade. Around the corner came a local primary school all dressed up as my Samurai Kids. Banging gongs and waving swords and banners. They marched down the main street and when they reached the dais their teacher yelled “Stop”. “Yes Sensei,” they responded.

Then they turned to face me and bowed, Japanese style. I stood and bowed too. And I bawled my eyes out. To be honest, I bawled my eyes out again writing this. It’s still such a vivid and emotional memory.

There are many times when I am asked why I don’t write proper books. Books for adults or older readers. Well one day I might write those too but in writing for kids, I am totally fulfilled. I do write proper books. The people who ask that question don’t understand the craft of writing for children. And they certainly don’t understand how wonderful young readers can make their authors feel. It’s real magic.

Thursday, 12 March 2009

Vampire Academy: Frostbite / Richelle Mead

Summary - A massive strigoi attack changes everything the Moroi and their dhampir guardians know. This attack puts St. Vladmirs on high alert, and with Christmas break coming the school decides all of the students, and their families will go to a remote royal ski resort.

Lissa and Christians relationship heats up, while Rose looks to Mason to help her put her feelings for her mentor Dimitri behind her. As if that’s not hard enough on Rose, she walks into a guardian class one day to suddenly see her mother for the first time in years.

After a second strigoi attack, 3 students leave the lavish ski resort in search of the strigoi to try to kill them. Rose joins forces with Christian to try to bring them back. But heroism rarely comes without a price…

Review - I was tough on Vampire Academy and I stand by that review but this book is a big improvement on the first in the series. Rose is still annoying as all heck - impulsive, ridiculous, selfish beyond belief then self-sacrificing and unbelievably petty. I still can't believe I am reading a novel when the main character grates on my last nerve. I maintain that I am reading it because of Dimitri. He and Christian are by far the most interesting of the bunch, Lissa's the personification of tepid bath....zzzzzz.

I love the whole exploration of the elitism of the Moroi/Dhampir class structure, especially in relation to the defence of both their species. That meeting where Tasha had her say was by far the most interesting scene I have experienced in this series (and by that, I mean I could have done without the voyeuristic Lissa/Christian love scene).

In my review of the first book I stated that I found Rose's mother to be immensely appealing despite her non appearance. This continues for me for one main reason, she kicks the protagonist's butt literally and figuratively. I loved every second. The relationship between mother and daughter is tense and strained. I love the development of this pairing and hope to see more of it. Yeah that's right, I am going to read Shadow Kiss.

One thing though, I couldn't stomach the prologue. If people need a catch up, they shouldn't be reading the book as far as I am concerned. I also think there was some lazy writing there. This series is capturing my attention and it's not due to Rose's fascination with describing how outrageously attractively she is or how outrageously attractive Dimitri is...I really have no idea why. Actually I think I do - the Strigoi attack and repercussion were quite well written and really captured my attention. As was the classist debate that was raised in the book. I do have to say though, I prefer Rose when she's in any other mode than man-eater becaue ultimately it's her flightiness and irresponsible dealings with guys that gets me offside.

Published: February 2009
Format: Paperback, 327 pages
Publisher: Penguin Aust.
Origin: USA

**UPDAT E Having read my review on the previous title I realised I wasn't actually all that hard on it. In fact I apparently like d Rose. So it was this book that made me dislike her...weird.

Wednesday, 11 March 2009

The Ice Cream Man / Jenny Mounfield

Summary - Playing a prank on the ice-cream man seems harmless enough at the time. After all, he asked for it! But what happens next ignites a terrifying chain of events that will bong three friends for life.

The ice-cream man is coming.

And he knows just where to find them.


Review - This is my third MG review in the past fortnight and I am really impressed by the quality of books I have been reading. This one is no different. The three main boys – Marty, Rick and Aaron – are all exceptionally characterised with different pressures at home. Marty has cerebral palsy and is straining to have any sense of independence, Rick’s father has died and his mother is an alcoholic and Aaron is tormented by his bullying step-brother. They all have tough situations at home and yet this story introduces the evil ice-cream man and their predicament get even worse!

My class was clamouring over this novel when it came in. The idea of a kid stalking, maniac ice cream man is too appealing. With the exception for my one student who actually has an ice cream van driving father (chances!) There is an exceptionally slow build which makes it a tense read with the use of the Pop Goes the Weasel tune, the phone calls and threats made. I think kids would really find themselves concerned for the welfare of their heroes. As an adult I could see some leaps of logic that kids would overlook but it is a great terrifying read for the independent reading set.

I can see many kids getting wrapped up in the story without realising that they are relating to kids that they may normally avoid. Marty is disabled but you wouldn’t know it, Aaron is overweight but extremely tech savvy and Rick is neglected but extremely loyal and resourceful. The strength of this book is in the depiction of kids that look different but are extremely relatable.

Thanks to Jenny, I am now a little wary of the ice cream man...and I have a parent / teacher interview with him in a couple of weeks!

Published: 2008
Format: Paperback, 187 pages
Publisher: Ford Street Publishing
Origin; Australia

Interview - Sandy Fussell

Sandy Fussell is a talented Australian author who will soon be launched into the American YA industry. She is also a techie as her day job is as a computer programmer. It's not a surprise then that she has a blog, an author's website and the Samurai Kids series website.

What was your inspiration and motivation in writing this series?
Japanese culture has always been a part of my life. I love Japanese cartoons. My current favourite is Avatar: The Last Air Bender. As a kid I watched The Samurai and The Phantom Agents on TV every chance I could. Then my friends and I would throw homemade ninja shuriken stars at each other and battle with tree branch samurai swords. They were dangerous times. On the other hand I have a real empathy for the wisdom of Zen –and kids get this too. When you take Zen to the extreme – to the most ludicrous end – then you have understanding. Sometimes I laugh and sometimes I understand.

How did you research Japan and the Samurai to make the kids' experience authentic?
I have a very vivid imagination and I read a lot of books but I haven’t been to Japan. So I make it up. It’s all about creating atmosphere. I wrote while listening to a shakuhachi flute. I went to sword fighting classes and a traditional tea ceremony. I ate lots of sushi (I love sushi!). This bit will sound incredibly boring but when writing historical fiction I like to read primary texts concurrently. While writing White Crane (the first Samurai Kids book) I read the legendary samurai Miyamoto Musashi’s Book of Five Rings over and over until suddenly the working day stopped beginning at 9 o’clock. It was the hour of the Dragon. I had started to think like a 17th century samurai.

The language you used is simple and yet very visual. How hard is that to keep consistent throughout a novel?
I like to create poetic images but I want to do it in such a way that younger readers and especially boys, will still read the words. Simple but descriptive language comes naturally to me. When I first started writing, I tried to write differently. It bothered me that my writing was too simple. My sentences were much shorter than those in books by ‘real’ writers.

At the same time I was attending lectures where editors talked about looking for ‘a different voice’ in writing. Then I realised that’s what my simple, visual sentences were – my voice. And different was good! Now I like the way my short sentences lend themselves to a quirky sort of humour. I get to be silly with words sometimes and it fits right in with the poetic stuff. Simple and visual is the only way I know to write!

Rhian Nest James has designed some beautiful art for your story. What was this partnership like?
Kids always ask me how I chose the illustrator. Or if Rhian and I went to school together. But I didn’t meet Rhian until the book launch. So it wasn’t really a partnership. More two people concentrating on what they do best with Sue Whiting (editor extraordinaire) in the middle joining it all together. Authors don’t get much input into illustrations and I think that this is a good thing. Let the illustrator draw and the author write. Except for those rare super talented individuals who can do both. I did see illustration roughs to check them for historical accuracy and to make sure all the swords were in the right places.

Rhian is enormously talented and very modest. I have no doubt her artwork is a huge contributing factor to the success of the series. She won’t agree. But I know kids look at the cover and immediately want to read the book.

The third of the series is about to be released. What are your continue plans for the series?
Sensei Ki-Yaga is preparing his students for a great battle to come. To meet the challenge they are learning (and I am exploring!) a range of skills from various martial arts disciplines. And that’s the thread linking all the books together. In Book 1, White Crane, the Kids began their samurai training.

In Book 2, Owl Ninja, they added ninja techniques. In Book 3, Shaolin Tiger, which is released on 1 April, they journey to China to study in a Shaolin Temple. Book 4, Monkey Fist, which is due out in August 2009, sees them travel to the Forbidden City (Beijing) to rescue Kyoko and learn Chinese ninja arts.

Along the way to obtaining these skills, they have many adventures. I never run out of ideas. It’s hard to tell when the series will end and I suspect the readers will dictate that. But I would like to add Tae Kwon Do to the Kids skill set and Book 4 did see them heading towards the Korean border…

Aussie YA/MG literature is going strong. Who are some OZYA authors you'd recommend to Pernickety Snark readers?
Such a hard question. Two of my favourite recent reads are Dianne Bates’ Crossing the Line and Mo Johnson’s Boofheads (both titles were reviewed on Persnickety Snark in February). Anthony Eaton’s Into White Silence and Finnikin of the Rock by Melina Marchetta open up wonderful different worlds - you can get lost in those books. I also like the YA novels of Bill Condon, with whom I am in a workshop group. I can guarantee his next novel is excellent. Finally, I am a huge Carole Wilkinson fan. If I could choose an Aussie book/series I wish I had written – it’s her Dragonkeeper series.

Thanks Sandy for granting me this interview. On Friday, come back and read her guest blog about one very special town and their celebration of her book.

Waiting on Wednesday (6)

This week I was kindly asked to write a guest blog for Liz over at the smashingly British, My Favourite Books. I wrote about the impact Forever by Judy Blume, had on me as a tween, a tween with exceedingly "square" tendencies. But more interestingly, from this guest blog, was the recommendation I received in the comments section. Luisa (the very Chicklish chickie) recommended that I get my hands on a specific title that I am now determined to get my hands on by hell or high water. Or maybe just purchase on Amazon, whatever is easier to conjure.

A Bad Boy Can Be Good For a Girl by Tanya Lee Stone

It's an oldie (relatively), published back in 2007 but I want it bad.

Josie, Nicolette and Aviva are three very different girls who all meet the same bad boy with an irresistible knack for getting into their blood and under their skin. Each is sure that she can keep a cool head about him, but how much are they really in control? A critical and word-of-mouth success in the US, this is a compulsive read that opens up the questions about love and sex that every girl needs to know.

What this description doesn't share is that Forever is a central part to the narrative. Hence the blatant gimme, gimme, gimme you've been hearing as you've read this post. It's four pounds which is probably sixty Australian dollars but me want, me want now (yes I lowered myself to referring to myself as me, thereby cementing my newly discovered level of pathetic).

Tuesday, 10 March 2009

The One and Only / Sophie McKenzie

Summary - Eve's dad has sent her to a convent school in Spain to keep her away from Luke. Lonely and miserable back in the UK, Luke finds himself tempted by another girl, Hayley - and ends up spending the night with her. Regretting it almost immediately, he hopes Eve will never find out - but then she turns up on his doorstep having run away. She says she's missed him so much and she wants them to finally sleep together - the first time for both of them, the perfect cementing of their enduring relationship. Luke knows he's messed up - but how can he tell Eve the truth? She thought she was Luke's one and only - he wishes she was...

Review - Something didn't sit right with this novel for me. I spent the entire read wondering if there was something more; more character development, more plot, more of anything. I felt very let down by the end and I couldn't shake it. Then I worked out via the author's website that it was the third in a series and everything fell into picture perfect clarity.

The character development that I felt was missing...wasn't so much, as it was present in the previous books (I am guessing). Though there were some nice moments, specifically any tense moments between Luke and his mother. And between Luke and Ryan. The storyline I enjoyed the most, it was probably the F-plot, was Luke's issues with his mother's new man in the face of his father's death. Could it be handled better? Maybe, but it was an intriguing idea and I think McKenzie brought some much needed spark to Luke with it's arc. Yet this was undone by the caricature of an angry, overprotective father and the stereotypical gay friend. Sigh.

As for Eve, I didn't see the attraction. I seriously could not see why Luke thought she was perfection incarnate and worth all that bother. I really dislike books that feature romance without sustainable character growth. It's like seeing Barbie and Ken kiss, entertaining for like a second and then you want to remove their heads (or was that just me?) If you aren't going to work the characters more then you need something gruesome, something tragic, something sparkly, something more. I didn't get the more in this novel and it disappointed me because I think McKenzie is capable of it.

I really believe that McKenzie is an author I could like but I think I may have started with the wrong title.

Published: April 1, 2009
Format: Paperback,
Publisher: Simon & Schuster
Origin: UK
_ _ _
Sophie McKenzie's Official Website

Teaser Tuesday (5)

Teaser Tuesday Terrific Time is here.

How's does it work, my kind friend?
I am glad you asked, Mr Hypothetical!

*Grab your current read
*Let the book fall open to a random page
*Share with us a “teaser” sentence from that page, somewhere between lines 7 and 12.

Title: The Secret Ministry of Frost
Author: Nick Lake
Vitals: Simon & Schuster, 2009

"He'd been torn in two during the peasant revolt, and only his lower half had ever been recovered."
p.21

Reader's Snapshot - Sandy Fussell

Sandy Fussell, author of Samurai Kids: White Crane and it's following sequels are to be released in the USA through Candlewick Press! Congrats to Sandy - another Aussie author making a start overseas. We'll be featuring Sandy on this blog through the week as our Author Spotlight!

Which book is memorable from your teen years?
Catch-22. Funny. Witty. Satiric. Up until then books had entertained me. But Catch-22was the first one that made me think . . .

Describe your high school English teacher in three words...
Only three words? Vic was my teacher for three years. He was an inspirational educator – way ahead of his time - but he told the worst jokes ever! Five years ago I tracked him down and now we’re good friends. I’m the second most famous author he knows – right behind Marcus Zusak who used to teach at his last school!

Your book of the moment?
I just finished Celeste Walters’ A Certain Music. It’s a new Aussie Random House (Woolshed Press) release. One of those ageless books – written for the junior market but with so much depth there are levels only a much older reader will find. I laughed and I cried. And I should have seen the end coming a mile a way but I was so busy experiencing the book I didn’t see the twist until I walked smack into it.

What do you use to mark your page when reading?
I have a wonderful crystal bookmark given to me by a good friend. It’s beautiful. But I am embarrassed to admit it never fitted my book quite right for about six months - that’s when I realised I was using it back-to-front! I do a lot of things back-to-front.

Favourite place to read?
Everywhere. On the school steps, at the bus stop, in the bath, in bed, at my desk when I’m supposed to be working…

Favourite word?
I have two and I found them both the same way. When I write I have the thesaurus from Answers.com open. I like to stumble around words – not to find a replacement – but to make them come alive by word association. And that’s how I found snizzle – a drizzle of snow and screak – the sound a bat makes. I love words that make a noise.

Favourite book store?
The Children’s Bookstore at Beecroft, NSW. I just wish I lived closer! It’s a magical place to browse with some terrific illustrator artwork on display. Their expert staff are a huge help selecting books. Absolutely essential if a younger reader is reluctant or has a reading level which doesn’t match their age. If you don’t get the right book, these kids don’t read. They give up right there and then. As a parent, I value how Ruth at The Children’s Bookstore always knows a title my youngest son will be keen to read.

Character you wish you had created?
Despereaux, the mouse in Kate Di Camillo’s The Tale of Despereaux. I hear the movie wasn’t very good but that shouldn’t be allowed to reflect on the character. He’s brilliant! A needle-waving, rat-braving, princess-saving hero! Works for me.

Bonus Question: I am adding some new contestants in the age old YA question - zombies, unicorns, cockroaches or dragons?
I guess I should cheerlead for the team and choose cockroaches - my Samurai kids belong to the Cockroach Ryu. But I’m a dragon person. Unicorns seem a little airy-fairy and zombies scare me. I remember skipping class to finish the latest in Anne McCaffrey’s Dragon Riders of Pern series.

Sandy Fussell's novel was reviewed on my site last month and you can read it here. Sandy has also just started a great blog of her own, reviewing children and YA titles.

Monday, 9 March 2009

The Thirteen Treasures / Michelle Harrison

Summary - While visiting her grandmother's house, an old photograph leads Tanya to an unsolved mystery. Fifty years ago a girl vanished in the woods nearby - a girl Tanya's grandmother will not speak of. Fabian, the caretaker's son, is tormented by the girl's disappearance. His grandfather was the last person to see her alive, and has lived under suspicion ever since. Together, Tanya and Fabian decide to find the truth. But Tanya has her own secret: the ability to see fairies. And, after disturbing an intruder in the night, it emerges that someone else shares her ability ...The manor's sinister history is about to repeat itself ...

Review - Tanya is an average twelve year old with one exception - she's got the second sight. This means she can see faeries, usually ugly, squat creatures that torment her with mischievous acts. After another Tanya versus faeries incident goes awry, her mother (having had enough) sends Tanya to stay with her cold grandmother at Elvesden Manor.

This debut effort won the UK's Waterstone's Prize and is a great little read. The plot was a little uneven at times but the adventures of Tanya and Fabian in investigating the disappearance of Morwenna Bloom was vastly entertaining. There is a mystery that involves both of their families, a boatload of magic and a lot of intrigue. While the narrative is nicely wrapped up and can be considered self-contained, there is definitely a lot of room to pursue a series here. I really enjoyed the idea that faeries are plentiful in our world and usually with evil motivations and a lot of hate. These faeries are a far cry from Tinkerbell, clapping in this book will only serve to incite a biting incident.

Tanya is very isolated from humans in this novel. Her mother dumps her with her old, frosty grandmother, cantankerous groundskeeper and his precocious and supremely annoying son, Fabian. Yet Tanya's whole world is tolerating and surviving the ever presence of faeries that refuse to leave her alone. The story is grim and grotty - the odours and grot that permeate this book are always felt by the reader. There is a definite atmosphere that has been created with expertise.

I really enjoyed this novel, it took awhile to get going but once it did I was captivated. It's a little darker than one might expect but I suspect that's why kids would like it. It doesn't condescend or talk down to the read, instead creates well rounded characters, a vivid setting and an intriguing plot.

Definitely worth the read if only for the mention of a faerie hunter!

Publisher: April 1 2009
Format: Paperback, 326 pages
Publisher: Simon & Schuster
Origin: UK
_ _ _
Christopher Gibbs talking about his work on the cover

**This is the third book with faeries I have read yet there has been not one unicorn or zombie novel come my way. Does that make me an automatic, unintentional member of Team Faerie?

The Disreputable History of Frankie Landau-Banks / E. Lockhart

Summary -
Frankie Landau-Banks at age 14:
Debate Club.
Her father's "bunny rabbit."
A mildly geeky girl attending a highly competitive boarding school.

Frankie Landau-Banks at age 15:
A knockout figure.
A sharp tongue.
A chip on her shoulder.
And a gorgeous new senior boyfriend: the supremely goofy, word-obsessed Matthew Livingston.

Frankie Landau-Banks.
No longer the kind of girl to take "no" for an answer.
Especially when "no" means she's excluded from her boyfriend's all-male secret society.
Not when her ex-boyfriend shows up in the strangest of places.
Not when she knows she's smarter than any of them.
When she knows Matthew's lying to her.And when there are so many, many pranks to be done.

Frankie Landau-Banks, at age 16:
Possibly a criminal mastermind.
This is the story of how she got that way.

Review - I have heard about this book for months and I should have known the hype would ruin it for me. That being said, I can't know for sure that I wouldn't feel the same about it had I read it with no knowledge. Simply put, I think it is a really well written novel with some great ideas but it really didn't gel for me. It wasn't to my taste, whereas it is for many people.

My problem - the third person narrative that floated in the present and future tense. It kept me too removed from the protagonist, which in turn didn't allow me to care all that much about her. (If I don't connect with the protagonist, I don't connect with the book.) It seemed a little too pretentious at times, dithering at others. Too much introspection and not enough detail into Frankie's machinations. The narration just plain annoyed me as it kept me at a distance and elements like the positive negatives, while cute were really clunky. It just seemed like in some areas of the book that the author was trying too hard. For instance, there are segments where Frankie goes on about Jeremy Bentham and the concept of panopticon - that felt like self-aggrandising to the worst degree.

I loved Lockhart's social commentary about the Old Boys Club mentality - so prolific in these arcane establishments. I was in one for four years and I think she has done a marvellous job as depicting the complete obliviousness and sometimes deliberateness there is in keeping females at bay. I like the themes of feminisism and proactiveness but it was undone for me by Frankie's belief that Matthew was the guy for her. I would have preferred that her motivations were in larger part the sexism issues than the Matthew's lying and exlcusion of her as was depicted in the novel. The scene between Matthew and Frankie in the sick bay didn't sit well with me. I didn't like Frankie in that scene, the respect that I had built for her was pretty much decimated. Don't get me wrong, I am being very critical but I did enjoy the book.


Lockhart's novel is a great, entertaining read and had it not been for the very specific, styled narrative I think I would have loved it. Regardless, I can appreciate the well crafted plot and the themes that are presented within it's pages.

Published: 2008
Format: Hardcover, 352 pages
Publisher: Hyperion Books
Origin: USA

_ _ _
E. Lockhart's Website

Sunday, 8 March 2009

In My Mailbox - 8 March

A Story Siren / Pop Culture Junkie Concept :

Ten Things I Hate About Me / Randa Abdel - Fattah (Aust.)
Dizzy / Cathy Cassidy
The One and Only / Sophie McKenzie (review asap)
Just Jealous / Anne Cassidy *
Monster Blood Tattoo: Foundling / DM Cornish
Monster Blood Tattoo: Lamplighter / DM Cornish
Oliver Nocturne: The Sunlight Slayings / Keith Emerson *
Oliver Nocturne: The Vampire's Photograph / Keith Emerson *
The Unicorn Chronicles: Into the Land of the Unicorns / Bruce Coville *
The Unicorn Chronicles: Song of the Wanderer / Bruce Coville *
The 13 Treasures / Michelle Harrison *
The Secret Ministry of Frost / Nick Lake *
The Princess Plot / Kirsten Boie *
The Disreputable History of Frankie Landau-Banks / E. Lockhart (review asap)
The Lucky Ones / Tohby Riddle (Aust.) *
The Vanishings / Michael Panckridge (Aust.)

I have had a great week but quite a few I bought at a Scholastic Book Fair. I am beginning to feel a little overwhelmed in how on earth I am going to review all these precious morsels but I guess you can only read one book's words at a time. A big thanks to S. of the Bermuda Triangle for lending The Disreputable History of Frankie Landau-Banks to me. It will be my first strike off my wish list - the Book Gods are turning their left corner of their mouths up in a semblance of a smile, it's progress. S. - it is going to be in the mail, back into your precious hands as soon as Australia Post can manage. (*=review priorities).

**Did the 'mature read' sticker give anyone else the giggles?

Soundtrack Saturday (5)

The guidelines for Soundtrack Saturday can be found above in the link bar. I am going to make this week's short as it relates to my other blog, The Sarah Dessen Diarist.

I am starting my responses forSarah Dessen's Just Listen and posted the playlist for the book. Sarah listed fourteen songs that inspired her in the writing of the book. The link to Sarah's blog mention is here.

1.”What It Feels Like For a Girl,” Madonna.
2. “Radio Song,” R.E.M.

3. “Road to Nowhere,” The Talking Heads.
4. “Drop the Pilot,” Mandy Moore.
5. “This is Radio Clash,” The Clash.
6. “Blind Love,” Tom Waits.
7. “Story of My Life,” Social Distortion.
8. “The Joker,” Fatboy Slim.
9. “Ooh Child,” Beth Orton.

10. “Ace of Spades,” Motorhead.
11. “Fight Test,” The Flaming Lips.
12. “You Belong to Me,” The Flat Duo Jets.
13. “Rebel Waltz,” The Clash.

14. “Thank You,” Tori Amos.

Sarah gives reasons for her choices at the previously mentioned link or alternatively, at my other blog. I have listened to this soundtrack on and off for the past six month and adore it. It introduced me to The Flaming Lips and The Format which I will always be grateful for. On my iPod it reads Sarah Dessen - Just Listen Mix (I have the Lock & Key one too :)